Friday, October 29, 2010

PROPOSAL FOR SUBMISSION

Research Topic:

Our research topic is about Augmented Reality. Augmented Reality is actually something not new and has already existed few years back then but most of us still do not know what augmented reality really is. Perhaps we have come across it once or twice but we never knew what it was and would treat it as something new and advance.

This technology, augmented reality is actually blurring the line between what is real and what is computer-generated by enhancing what we see, hear, feel and smell. We would want to know what is actually augmented reality and how is it applied into businesses. Take for example, some businesses allows customers to shop using this augmented reality technology as a different way to present their products. This technology is being adopted into the e-commerce, where it may eventually bring upon a revolution in the way on how people do their shopping.

We would want to know what is actually augmented reality and how is it applied into our life, such as the most popular iPhone itself has actually adapted to this technology, providing users of this technology through its applications. Some says that iPhone will be a key turning point in popularizing the technology. Take for example, in the Netherlands; users can use an application called “Layar” that uses the phone’s camera and GPS capabilities to gather information about the surrounding areas. This application will then show users the nearest locations on restaurants or other sites in the surroundings.

Video games can also be added graphics, sounds, and even smell to the natural as it exists. Cell phone and video games are now starting to turn their research and development to augmented reality. Everyone from tourist, to soldiers, and so on can now benefit from the ability to place computer-generated graphics in their field of vision. This technology is actually changing the way we view the world.


Rationale of topic choice:

Why is augmented reality an interesting topic to us? Most of us may have come across this technology but we never bother to know or even know what this technology is called. It is quite a disappointment when we know that this technology had already been around for quite some time already and before we knew this, we thought that it is actually some recent technology. Therefore, we are doing this topic in order to know more on this augmented reality technology and also its uses in different areas. We attempt to also research on the benefits and limitations of this augmented reality technology. Can this augmented reality pull up the standard of living of the human population? Or is it merely just a technology that goes no where? We are also interested in its application in e-commerce; on how it can help businesses to achieve better presentation of products to the customer, such as in shopping using this augmented reality technology.

In terms of not knowing augmented reality, is augmented reality not efficient? Or perhaps it is not suitable for users in dealing with our needs. We will attempt to research and to know what the benefits are and also limitations for this augmented reality technology. We will first of all introduce to how augmented reality is really functioned and also find how on how it can contribute to the society especially in e-commerce.

Once we get to know on this technology, we will have a better understanding of what augmented reality can really offers and perhaps it might be useful for us in the near future. Perhaps the next generation coming up will fully adapt to this technology and we, as the older generations by then are able to cope with this technology too.


Research paper’s objective:

  • To understand how augmented reality is functioned, where this research introduces its appearance, how does it work and its approach to the users.
  • To find out how can it contribute to the society in the business fields, especially in e-commerce, manufacturing line, education and also mobile. This overall discuss mainly on the cost and benefits that it can provide to the users as a whole.
  • To analyse the issues involved, strategies and also the future direction of augmented reality (such as the effectiveness and benefits, limitations and also the current and future directions of the augmented reality).

Report Outline:

1.0              Introduction
1.1              Research objective
1.2              Definition of AR
1.3              Rationale of topic choice

2.0              Software of AR

3.0       Applications
            3.1       Business and Manufacturing line
            3.2       Education
            3.3       Mobile
            3.4       Current and Future

4.0       Issues
            4.1       Effectiveness and Benefits
            4.2       Limitations and Unexpected Dangers

5.0              Conclusion

6.0              Recommendations

7.0              References

Literature Review:
According to Roberts et.al (2002), Augmented Reality (AR) is a technology based on virtual reality where virtual data is placed over onto real life images, ensuing in a combination of the two background. AR fills the area between the real world and the virtual world. It takes the information character of the virtual world and makes them effortlessly reachable and relevant to the user. AR is not only a visually based coordination but another medium that is normally augmented onto reality is the element of sound (Roberts, 2000). AR can be thought of as the "middle ground" between virtual environments (completely synthetic) and telepresence (completely real) (Miligram et.al 1994).  In contrast, AR allows the user to see the real world, with virtual objects superimposed upon or composited with the real world. Therefore, AR supplements reality, rather than completely replacing it (Azuma 1997).

According to Peter Grad 2010, “Augmented reality — AR in techspeak — is becoming more of an everyday reality for millions of smart-phone users these days. AR is becoming a powerful weapon for consumers in search of good buys. The iPhone’s Red Laser application scans product bar codes and instantly displays a list of nearby stores and prices. And it does more: Scan a book bar code in a store, for example, and not only will you get competitor store prices, you will also be shown prices at online sites such as Amazon and half.com, that often offer books at steep discounts.” AR uses specially designed markers to regulate the camera and track the movement of the indicator for the augmentation of 3D product models. Only simple hardware is required for this system except a PC camera (Zhang, Navab & Liou 2002).

In recent years, Junaio is one of the examples of more user-centric world browsers allocating clients to tag and upload content as they come across it in the real world and to share and ascertain the information that other users have uploaded (Reynolds et.al 2010).  According to Paul Golding (2010), Junaio is the next-generation mobile augmented-reality browser for camera-equipped device.

According to Wagner & Schmalstieg (2007), during the past years, ARToolKit is the major low-cost optical tracking solution for many AR developers. It is fit for tracking solutions for many functions, as it works with one optical eye effective in the evident light range, therefore allows a handheld mechanism to work freely relying only on passive infrastructure, making it a first choice for a single tracking solution on mobile devices such as PDAs. ARToolKit employs computer vision method to estimate the real camera stance relative to a real world marker (Kato,Billinghurst &Poupyrev 2000). Besides ARToolKit, there are also many other AR platforms such as DART and Studierstube, which can also provide an easy to use tool allowing anyone who has or no AR background to rapidly develop AR applications from initial concept designs to final designs and developments.

According to Huang et.al (2010), AR has been used in multiple areas such as education, entertainment, advertisement, market shopping, etc. AR technique can be used in sales, advertisement of market where consumer can get plenty of product information and services. E-commerce based AR was developed to provide shopping assistance and personalized advertising. AR is particularly powerful for educational purposes when users are collocated and can use natural means of communication, but can also be mixed successfully with immersive VR or remote collaboration (Shelton 2002) According to Azuma (1997), assembly, maintenance, and repair of complex machinery are areas of AR application development. Instructions might be easier to understand if they were accessible, not as guidebook with text and pictures, but rather as 3-D drawings overlaying upon the actual equipment, showing gradually the tasks that required to be completed and how to enforce them. These overlay 3-D drawings can be dynamic, making the instructions even more precise.

As said by Lawrence Swaider, “Augmented reality will become easier and easier and become seamless parts of our lives”. Mobile phones would be the most convenient hardware for AR to work and would be the future trend of focus for AR yet more research has to be conducted for metaphors and techniques (Haller, Billinghurst & Thomas 2007)


Major References:

·         Ronald T. Azuma, Hughes Research Laboratories, “A survey of Augmented Reality”, viewed 28 October 2010.

This is a survey on the current state-of-the-art in Augmented Reality. It describes work performed at many different sites and explains the issues and problems encountered when building Augmented Reality systems. Sites referred to are such as in medical, manufacturing, visualization, path planning, entertainment and also military applications. It summarizes the tradeoffs and approaches taken so far to overcome these problems and speculates on future directions that deserve exploration. This article had aid us on discussing the application of AR in Business and manufacturing line. It provides us some guidelines and also how the AR helps in the manufacturing line. Besides that, it also allows us to know more or less on the limitations of the AR which give us roughly an idea that greatly assisted in our research.


·         R. Silva, J. C. Oliveira, G. A. Giraldi, National Laboratoty for Scientific Computation, “Introduction to Augmented Reality”, viewed 28 October 2010.

This reports an overview of basic aspects of Augmented Reality (AR) and the main concepts of this technology. It describes the main fields in which AR is applied nowadays and important AR devices. Some characteristics of Augmented Reality systems were discussed and this paper will provide an overview of them. Besides that, the future directions of AR were also discussed. We have learnt from this article some of the future applications and challenges that we take into account for our discussion when analyzing the current and also future directions of augmented reality.


·         S. K. Ong, M. L. Yuan, A. Y. C. Nee, Published by Taylor & Francis, “Augmented reality applications in manufacturing: a survey”, Mechanical Engineering Department, National University of Singapore, viewed 28 October 2010.

This paper provides a comprehensive survey of developed and demonstrated AR applications in manufacturing activities. The intention of this survey is to provide researchers, students, and engineers, who use or plan to use AR as a tool in manufacturing research, a useful insight on the state-of-the-art AR applications and developments. Therefore, it had actually provided us a lot of information for our discussion on augmented reality, especially on our discussion on manufacturing line and also businesses.


·         David Drascic and Paul Milgram, “Perceptual Issues in Augmented Reality”, Department of Mechanical and Industrial Engineering, University of Toronto, viewed 28 October 2010.

The article identifies and discusses eighteen issues that pertain to Mixed Reality in general and Augmented Reality in particular. The paper also creates awareness on the problems that may be of the system and design systems around the weaknesses that these perceptual issues can create. This enables us to gain more understanding on the limitations on AR and also the solution to the problems of AR. It helped a lot in our discussion for the limitations and unexpected dangers of AR.

·         Wayne Pierkarski and Bruce H. Thomas, “Using ARToolKit for 3D Hand Position Tracking in Mobile Outdoor Environments”, University of South Australia, viewed 28 October 2010

This paper describes how we have used the ARToolKit to perform three degrees of freedom tracking of the hands, in world coordinates, which is used to interact with a mobile outdoor augmented reality computer. It aids us in discussing the problem of making ARToolKit to generate world coordinates, and the solutions we developed to meet the requirements for our tracking system. It also helps us to understand on how the ARToolKit has allowed integrating hand tracking into their outdoor modeling applications.


Other References:
Alan B.Craig, William R. Sherman, Jeffrey D. Will, Developing Virtual Reality Applications: Foundations of effective design, last viewed 28 October 2010, http://books.google.com.my/books?id=2P91gPYr5KkC&printsec=frontcover&dq=developing+virtual+reality+applications&hl=en&ei=yWKxTLawHY7-vQPt1q2mBg&sa=X&oi=book_result&ct=result&resnum=1&ved=0CC8Q6AEwAA#v=onepage&q&f=false

ARToolKit, ARToolKit Home Page, last viewed 28 October 2010, http://www.hitl.washington.edu/artoolkit/

Christine Bardwell, Augmented reality boosts retail sales, but where is the ROI?, June 2010, last viewed 28 October 2010, http://mis-asia.com/opinion__and__blogs/bloggers/augmented-reality-boosts-retail-sales,-but-where-is-the-roi

Demystifyingusability, What’s next in mobile user experience? Augmented Reality, September 2009, last viewed 28 October 2010, http://www.demystifyingusability.com/2009/09/augmented-reality-user-experience.html


EDUCAUSE Learning Initiative, 7 things you should know about Augmented Reality, September 2005, last viewed 28 October 2010, http://net.educause.edu/ir/library/pdf/ELI7007.pdf


Junaio, Make the World Yours!, Metaio Inc. 2010, last viewed 28 October 2010, http://www.junaio.com/

Mark Billinghurst, Augmented Reality in Education, December 2002, last viewed 28 October 2010, http://www.newhorizons.org/strategies/technology/billinghurst.htm

Metaio Augmented Solutions, Create Mobile Augmented Reality Experiences, last viewed 28 October 2010, http://www.metaio.com/products/mobile/

MIT Press, Augmented Learning – Ebooks at the MIT Press, last viewed 28 October 2010, http://mitpress-ebooks.mit.edu/product/augmented-learning

UTC by arn, Impressive Augmented Realitu Game Possibilities on the iPhone, GDC 2009, last viewed 28 October 2010, http://toucharcade.com/2009/03/26/impressive-augmented-reality-game-possibilities-on-the-iphone/

WSJ.com 2009, Esquire Experiments with a Digital Reality, last viewed 28 October 2010, http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052748704222704574501122991439500.html?mod=article-outset-box

Yuka Yoneda, Solar Powered Augmented Contact Lenses Cover Your Eye With 100s of LEDs, 3/17/10, last viewed 28 October 2010, http://www.inhabitat.com/2010/03/17/solar-powered-augmented-contact-lenses-cover-your-eye-with-100s-of-leds/

Sunday, October 10, 2010

Blog Discussion: Current & Future of Augmented Reality Applications

Current applications
Traditional e-commerce systems have reached a limitation that needs to be overcome, because they do not provide enough direct information for online shoppers, especially when they are shopping for products like furniture, clothing, shoes, jewellery and other decorative e-products. Therefore, I believe that AR would be the latest break through for a new era of e-commerce.

E-shopping

Online shopping has been in the trend for quite some time. But, problems such as items seen on the screen were not as expected. Therefore, with the use of AR, these problems can be solved. This technology has been used by some companies and is gaining quite a bit of positive response. Imagine you are shopping for clothes, what colors would suit you more? Try on the clothes while E-shopping was impossible in the past. But now, with AR applications, anyone can tryout the clothes without the real thing with you. The size and color would be the same. The only thing you can’t feel would be the texture of the cloth itself.

Advertising
In commerce, advertising is a point of decision of the success of a business. A successful advertising is more powerful than words, it’s a presentation of you product to the world. Therefore, a company can build up their strong brand name by promoting their products or introduce their products to the public that can create awareness to the public for their products. For example, The Wellington Zoo is a successful example of AR advertising. The advertising campaign led to a 32% increase in visitors to thee “Close Encounter” exhibit. The advertising has earned numerous awards and honors as well.

Future applications

The world is moving towards a new revolution. In no time, the age of computers would be over and comes a new era, the dawn of holograms, Augmented Reality. Computer screens would no longer be needed as the screen is brought into real life environment. Windows and icons would appear as virtual devices in real spaces by eye or gesture operated. The naked eye with an addition of camera device would show the person the world with a whole new prospective, the prospective of an augmented reality world.

The traditional screens would no longer be needed, along with the platforms of the computer. Only small pieces of devices which are compatible to be carried around in devices such as mobile phones would be needed. Such devices may one day be replaced by AR contact lenses as well to be fashion wise, yet compatibility and convenience. The view would no longer be what they were, but so much more add-ons with it. A historical monument would be tagged with the history of it in a dialogue box. All data would be without boundaries. The appearance of anyplace could be changed or replaced with a whole new panoramic view. Imagine, your bedroom usual wallpaper would no longer be dull, but with scenery of hilltops or in desert or just anywhere you please. With AR application, much more things such as virtual window dressing, posters, traffic sign, and advertisement towers can be improved.

All this will one day lead to virtual thingamajig. Any physical device currently produced to assist in data-oriented tasks such as the clock, radio, PC, PDA, PMP, informational posters, billboards, in-car navigation systems and so on could be replaced by virtual devices that cost nothing bits of devices such as a spectacle-like eyewear. The simplest example would be a virtual wall clock or a to-do list for the day beside your bed for you to look at first thing in the morning.


References:

http://books.google.com.my/books?id=N8deh8UXcGEC&pg=PA932&dq=human+computer+interaction:+interation+platform+and+technique&hl=en&ei=UWKxTIqOHomgvgPck5CABw&sa=X&oi=book_result&ct=result&resnum=1&ved=0CC0Q6AEwAA#v=onepage&q&f=false
http://books.google.com.my/books?id=2P91gPYr5KkC&printsec=frontcover&dq=developing+virtual+reality+applications&hl=en&ei=yWKxTLawHY7-vQPt1q2mBg&sa=X&oi=book_result&ct=result&resnum=1&ved=0CC8Q6AEwAA#v=onepage&q&f=false

http://spectrum.ieee.org/
http://www.inhabitat.com/2010/03/17/solar-powered-augmented-contact-lenses-cover-your-eye-with-100s-of-leds/

Blog Discussion: Limitations & Unexpected Dangers of Augmented Reality

After years of research, AR has been developing in an amazing pace. In short years, it would surely dwell into our everyday life and become a part of it. Yet now, despite the innovative and promising character of AR applications there are still lots of barriers to overcome in order to ensure consistency and efficacy of the AR approach. Optical, technical and human-factor limitations are still at large to be resolved.

One of the limitations would be of the computer generated virtual objects must be accurately registered with the real world in all dimensions. Meaning, the objects in the real and virtual worlds must be properly aligned with respect to each other, or the illusion that the two worlds coexist will be compromised. Without accurate registration, AR will not be accepted in many applications, as the errors in this registration will prevent the users from seeing the real and virtual images as merged.

Registration errors are hard to adequately control because of the high accuracy requirements and the numerous sources of error, which are static error and dynamic error. Static errors are the ones that cause registration errors even when the user’s viewpoint and the objects in the environment remain completely still. On the other hand, either dynamic errors are the ones that have no effect until the viewpoint or the objects begin moving. Up to now, dynamic errors are by far the major contributors to registration errors, but static errors cannot be ignored either. According to Azuma, when the user is operating an AR system in a static, or fixed, context the errors are usually derived from distortion in the head mount display (HMD) optics, mechanical misalignments in the HMD, errors in the headtracking system.

Yet, the AR functions are believed to be too complex for commercial applications purposes. This is due to the low image quality and hardware limitations current camera adapted devices such as PDA, mobile phones or webcams. Technical limitations relating with movement tracking and display is still currently lacking accuracy. But, this is still solvable with powerful equipments. For instance, the camera on our mobile phones would be one of the ways to apply some basic applications. As such, it is firmly believed that due to the complexities in AR, even though engineers are able to have the potential ability to create a reliable system, as because of the hardware inconsistencies, error in human calculations, software failures, and response time delays, we will not ever have a perfect AR system.

All of this would be fixed, but with a lump sum of investment into it. Even after perfection, companies would still consider whether or not to invest into it as it would be costly at first to invest into all the machinery supplies. LEGO for example would have to purchase screens for the retail shops as well as the cameras to capture the movements of the customer and product on it. The costs of the software itself and the extra costs of the packaging itself is still yet to be counted in. Therefore, is there really any need for this new technology to be added on to products would still be a puzzle?

Over with the limitations, and now into the unexpected dangers of AR. First of all would be the privacy issues. AR, without doubt would arise privacy issues as it could invade the privacy of organizations into it. This would mean both internal as well as external users. Both would happen to have access to information of the business. For example, if used on persons in a dating company, all personal data would be revealed on the person to others, this means also to complete strangers causing unwarranted breaches of privacy. With the AR technology invented, it would not be just Twitter that lets users to “geotag” their online data, but everything will. With the rise of AR applications merged with “geotagging”, and “interesting” phenomenon will happen: there are going to be moments when you either reveal who you are, or where you are at exactly the most inopportune instant (Kit Eaton 2009). So, in the coming future, how are you going to protect your “geotagging” along with your other online data?

Social acceptance is also being seen as a dispute in this field. Given a system with ultimate hardware and an instinctive edge which is yet to be achieved, how can AR become an accepted part of a user’s everyday life, just like a mobile phone or a personal digital assistant (PDA)? Through the media, many people are familiar with images of simulated AR. However, enforcing this technology in our everyday life means arising number of issues. These range from public acceptance to privacy concerns. What if a person sees another and with the use of AR applications, withdraws the clothes from the images transmitted into the image capturing device and recorded it. Would it not be a crime to do so? Who would it be to judge. To date, little attention has been placed on these fundamental issues. However, these must be addressed before AR becomes widely accepted.

With this sort of AR technology, eventually the society would be totally different. There would be no more need of sales assistant in this society. Let’s think of it, schools would be without teachers, travel agency industry would no longer be needed and you should know about the shops, it’s without sales assistants. All of these would be replaced with holographic images of them. There would be no need of manpower anymore in these industries. . For this particular reason, one must think how it will be utilized for the sake of humankind, and how it will be able to get man involved into the total workforce as well. Otherwise all this technology brings not convenience to the human race, but a total nightmare.

References:

http://books.google.com.my/books?id=P00EWiefUWQC&pg=PA440&dq=limitations+of+augmented+reality&hl=en&ei=cmaxTJfLF5TEvQOh1Pz4Bg&sa=X&oi=book_result&ct=result&resnum=1&ved=0CCsQ6AEwAA#v=onepage&q=limitations%20of%20augmented%20reality&f=false